Friday, July 30, 2010

Manipulation in Journalistic Photography (Assignment 1, Topic 3)

Journalistic photography is a very important tool used in telling a story that is meant to be a reflection of reality. They are meant to communicate a message that forms the entire feeling of the story. When photos used in journalism are manipulated to the extent where they completely alter the message, ethical issues can arise.
Journalists can use photo manipulation in various ways. Subtle alterations can be used to simply enhance the quality of the photograph, such as adjusting lighting and coloration, which typically does not change the overall message of the story. In other cases, journalists can manipulate their photos in order to propagandise them to sway the opinion of their readers in a particular direction.

Manipulation techniques have been used for decades in journalistic photography. Below is an example of how photo manipulation in journalism has been used to create propaganda.
The original photo is one that includes Joseph Stalin, Nikolai Yezhov, and Leon Trotsky. Stalin had Trotsky taken out of the photograph in the second image for propaganda purpose, negating any affiliation between the two. This completely changes the message of the image. After Yezhov was executed some years later, he was also edited out of this photograph, therefore implying that he did not exist in affiliation with Stalin.

The next image shows an original photo and the altered version of Jaques Steinberg, a New York Times reporter, who was accused by Fox News of writing attack stories about them. When they showed the image of Steinberg, it was digitally altered in order to make Mr. Steinberg look much uglier then how he actually appears. This is done to create
a message that this man is a hideous human being trying to cause damage to Fox News, and by making him look like more of an ogre it creates much more of an impact then his actual appearance would. This can be seen as a form of modern day propaganda used by journalists.

References:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photo_manipulation
http://mediamatters.org/research/200807020002
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCHrd5q9Kcc